Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Evergreen Island Homes For Sale
A Complete Guide to Living in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

Work With Sarah Schwartz, Realtor - A Silverleaf Focused Real Estate Specialist

Evergreen Island quick facts: prices, home sizes, builder, HOA, year built, and property types.

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf: New Homes in St. Augustine, FL

For buyers exploring Evergreen Island homes for sale, this gated community offers two collections of single-family homes for sale in Evergreen Island: Classic, on 40-foot homesites from $457,900, and Executive, from $449,900 to $789,900. Built by the reputed David Weekley Homes, the two collections together span roughly 1,767 to 3,048 square feet, with 3 to 5 bedrooms and 1- to 2-car garages, giving buyers considering homes for sale in Evergreen Island a genuine range of sizes and different price points.

Evergreen Island sits within Silverleaf, a roughly 11,000-acre master-planned community in St. Johns County. The homesites here are laid out along Lucia Place, Ancient Springs Lane, Whimsical Meadow Lane, McCallum Court, and Halcyon Island Drive, surrounded by a central pond. Buyers searching for Evergreen Island new homes for sale will find a gated entrance, a swimming pool and spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and a clubhouse already in place, along with no CDD fees community-wide and a firehouse and urgent care facility located right within Silverleaf.

Evergreen Island Frequently Asked Questions

Sarah Schwartz Realtor

Meet Sarah, Expert Realtor In Evergreen Island

For comprehensive real estate services in Evergreen Island, your go-to person should be Sarah. Having grown up in the area, she knows the real estate territory inside and out. With her expertise and years of experience in real estate, Sarah guides buyers and sellers to feel completely comfortable when purchasing or selling their home in Evergreen Island.

For Sarah, every real estate transaction is a highly personalized approach. Even before she starts to work for you, Sarah takes time to understand your lifestyle requirements, wants and needs so that she can help you get your dream home or sell your home for the highest value.

Here are some of the reasons that make Sarah a top Realtor in Evergreen Island.

✔ Community-certified, award-winning SilverLeaf agent
✔ SilverLeaf expert offering precise neighborhood insights
✔ In-depth understanding of the homebuilder process
✔Deep pricing insight specific to communities
✔ Wide-ranging expertise in buyer/seller negotiation
✔ Consistent client communication and quick service

.

Aerial view of homes beside a lake with a fountain and wooded shoreline.

Silverleaf: A Master-Planned Community in St. Johns County

Silverleaf is one of the largest master-planned communities in Northeast Florida, spanning roughly 11,000 acres in St. Johns County between County Road 210 and State Road 16, just west of Interstate 95.

The community is zoned for approximately 17,600 homes and 2.9 million square feet of mixed-use and commercial space. It has more than 4,350 acres permanently preserved as conservation land and over 50 miles of sidewalks and golf cart paths connecting its neighborhoods.

Silverleaf consists of several distinct neighborhoods, including Hidden Creek at Johns Island, Waterford Lakes, Elm Creek, Silver Landing, Brandon Lakes, Silverleaf Village, Holly Forest, Silver Falls, Brook Forest, and the 55+ community Reverie at Silverleaf. Homes are built by a mix of respected builders, including David Weekley Homes, Dream Finders Homes, D.R. Horton, ICI Homes, Lennar, MasterCraft Builder Group, Richmond American Homes, Riverside Homes, Taylor Morrison, and Toll Brothers.

Notably, Silverleaf residents pay no CDD fees. Reach out to Sarah to explore new construction and homes for sale across Silverleaf’s neighborhoods.

Aerial view of neighboring homes along a residential street, with driveways and lawns.

Silverleaf: A Master-Planned Community in St. Johns County

Silverleaf is one of the largest master-planned communities in Northeast Florida, spanning roughly 11,000 acres in St. Johns County between County Road 210 and State Road 16, just west of Interstate 95.

The community is zoned for approximately 17,600 homes and 2.9 million square feet of mixed-use and commercial space. It has more than 4,350 acres permanently preserved as conservation land and over 50 miles of sidewalks and golf cart paths connecting its neighborhoods.

Silverleaf consists of several distinct neighborhoods, including Hidden Creek at Johns Island, Waterford Lakes, Elm Creek, Silver Landing, Brandon Lakes, Silverleaf Village, Holly Forest, Silver Falls, Brook Forest, and the 55+ community Reverie at Silverleaf. Homes are built by a mix of respected builders, including David Weekley Homes, Dream Finders Homes, D.R. Horton, ICI Homes, Lennar, MasterCraft Builder Group, Richmond American Homes, Riverside Homes, Taylor Morrison, and Toll Brothers.

Notably, Silverleaf residents pay no CDD fees. Reach out to Sarah to explore new construction and homes for sale across Silverleaf’s neighborhoods.

.

Evergreen Island neighborhood entrance with blue signs, palm trees, and homes along the road.

New Construction Homes in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

Every home in Evergreen Island is newly constructed, built exclusively by David Weekley Homes, a Jacksonville-based builder with more than 45 years of experience. Buyers can choose from the Classic Collection on 40-foot homesites or the upgraded Executive Collection, with new homes for sale in Evergreen Island ranging from 1,767 to 3,048 square feet across both.

For buyers comparing new build homes for sale in Evergreen Island, the sitemap shows a mix of available, quick move-in, sold, and model homesites across the community, so timing and homesite selection both matters. Buyers interested in Evergreen Island new construction homes should confirm current availability with Sarah, since inventory shifts as David Weekley continues to release new homesites.

Evergreen Island Sitemap

Evergreen Island New Construction Details

Builders

One Builder, Two Distinct Collections

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf is developed exclusively by David Weekley Homes, a Jacksonville-based builder with more than 45 years of experience delivering award-winning design, choice, and service. This single-builder approach means every home across both the Classic and Executive collections follows the same construction standards, even though home sizes, finish levels, features, and price points vary. Buyers can therefore compare the two collections while maintaining confidence in the builder’s established approach to quality and craftsmanship.

Within Evergreen Island, the Classic Collection offers single-family homes on 40-foot homesites starting at $457,900. The Executive Collection includes six named floor plans, the Borland, Charlesworth, Danielle, Hollinger, Navarro, and Boling, ranging from $462,900 to $559,900 and up, with 3 to 4 bedrooms, 2 to 3 bathrooms, and 1,916 to 3,048 square feet. Buyers interested in the brand-new houses for sale in Evergreen Island can visit the sales center at 80 Mariana Island Drive to compare both collections and explore their available options in person.

Because David Weekley builds throughout the community, buyers benefit from a consistent warranty and construction standard whether they select a Classic homesite or an upgraded Executive floor plan. Executive homes also offer features such as 10-foot ceilings and smooth walls for buyers seeking additional interior detail. For buyers who want new construction homes in Evergreen Island from a single, locally rooted builder, David Weekley’s exclusive role in the community remains an important part of its appeal. This also makes comparing homes and features easier for buyers today.

Lot Characteristics

40-Foot Homesites Around a Central Pond

Evergreen Island’s Classic Collection is built on 40-foot homesites, while Executive Collection lot widths vary depending on the floor plan and location within the community. Homesites are arranged along Lucia Place, Ancient Springs Lane, Whimsical Meadow Lane, McCallum Court, and Halcyon Island Drive, with the neighborhood’s streets wrapping around a central pond. This layout gives many homesites the opportunity to enjoy water views while maintaining the community’s quiet, residential setting.

Buyers considering new single-family homes for sale in Evergreen Island on a specific lot type should review the neighborhood’s sitemap carefully, as it shows a mix of available, quick move-in, sold, and model homesites. Pond-view and other premium locations may become unavailable sooner than interior lots, making homesite selection an important part of the buying process. The community’s location near State Road 23 and the First Coast Expressway also provides convenient regional access, while the interior streets maintain a quieter, tree-lined residential atmosphere.

Buyers interested in new homes at Evergreen Island who prefer a pond-view or corner homesite should work with Sarah to review current availability and location options. Since Evergreen Island at Silverleaf continues to offer homes across both the Classic and Executive collections, buyers can compare different homesite widths and floor plans based on their preferences. Premium lots are limited, so checking current inventory can help buyers identify the locations that best match their desired home style, views, and overall needs within the community.

Future Development

What’s Next for Evergreen Island and Silverleaf

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf continues to release new homesites and quick move-in homes across both the Classic and Executive collections as David Weekley builds toward the community’s full capacity. The sitemap shows a mix of available, quick move-in, sold, and model homesites, giving buyers interested in Evergreen Island new homes meaningful options to consider. Because inventory continues to change as homes are sold and new opportunities become available, buyers can benefit from reviewing current homesite and floor plan availability when planning a purchase. The two collections also provide flexibility for buyers comparing different home sizes, designs, and homesite locations.

At the broader Silverleaf level, the master-planned community continues to grow across its roughly 11,000 acres, adding retail, commercial space, and additional neighborhoods over time. For Evergreen Island residents, this continued growth means expanding access to shopping, dining, and amenities throughout Silverleaf. These broader offerings complement the pool, spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and clubhouse already available within the community itself, creating a lifestyle that combines neighborhood recreation with the conveniences of a larger master-planned community.

For buyers considering new construction Evergreen Island homes today, the combination of two active collections, changing inventory, and Silverleaf’s continued growth nearby makes the community an appealing option. Buyers who have specific preferences for a floor plan, homesite, or quick move-in home should review current availability as the selection can narrow over time. This allows them to identify opportunities that best match their needs and priorities.

Evergreen Island At Silverleaf Floorplans

.

SilverLeaf New Construction Neighborhoods

All SilverLeaf Neighborhoods

.

Evergreen Island Neighborhood Details

Lifestyle

Amenity-Rich Living at Evergreen Island

Life in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf centers on privacy, convenience, and a range of home options within the same community setting. As a gated community with two collections, Evergreen Island offers single-family homes on 40-foot Classic homesites as well as larger Executive floor plans. This variety gives buyers the flexibility to choose a home based on their preferred size, layout, and lifestyle without having to leave the same amenity-rich neighborhood.

Buyers moving to Evergreen Island often consider the community’s amenities a major part of its appeal. Residents have access to a swimming pool and spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and a clubhouse with multiple pavilions, all located within the gated community. Additional conveniences are available throughout Silverleaf, including a firehouse and urgent care facility, while nearby shopping, dining, and entertainment options make everyday errands and leisure activities easy to incorporate into daily life. Within Evergreen Island, streets such as Lucia Place, Ancient Springs Lane, and Whimsical Meadow Lane wind around the community’s central pond, giving many homesites a peaceful, natural backdrop.

With its gated setting, dedicated neighborhood amenities, and convenient location within Silverleaf, homes for sale in Evergreen Island appeal to a broad range of homebuyers. First-time buyers may find the Classic Collection an appealing option, while growing families, move-up buyers, or downsizers may prefer the larger Executive floor plans. This combination of home variety, recreation, and convenient access to surrounding Silverleaf amenities gives residents multiple ways to enjoy the community while remaining close to everyday necessities and regional destinations.

Evergreen Island Amenities

A Full Amenity Package Offered by Evergreen Island

Residents of Evergreen Island Silverleaf home for sale listings have access to a full on-site amenity package that supports recreation, relaxation, and everyday community living. The amenities include a swimming pool and spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and a clubhouse with multiple pavilions, all located within Evergreen Island’s gated boundary. These facilities give residents convenient options for staying active, spending time outdoors, and gathering with friends and neighbors. A firehouse and urgent care facility within Silverleaf add another layer of everyday convenience close to home.

his on-site amenity package helps distinguish Evergreen Island from communities that rely more heavily on shared master-planned facilities located elsewhere in Silverleaf. Residents also benefit from nearby shopping, dining, and entertainment options, giving buyers considering gated homes for sale at Evergreen Island access to both recreation and everyday conveniences within a comfortable distance. Whether residents want to exercise, enjoy a weekend swim, or spend time outdoors, several amenities are available without needing to travel far from home.

For buyers comparing Evergreen Island Silverleaf house for sale options with other Silverleaf communities, having a pool, spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and clubhouse already available within the neighborhood is a notable advantage. The combination of established amenities, a gated setting, and convenient access to Silverleaf’s broader offerings gives Evergreen Island a well-rounded residential environment for buyers seeking both comfort and recreation.

Home Descriptions

Classic and Executive Collections by David Weekley Homes

Homes for sale in Evergreen Island span two David Weekley collections, giving buyers a choice of home sizes, layouts, and finish levels within the same community. The Classic Collection offers single-family homes on 40-foot homesites starting at $457,900, with floor plans designed around practical, everyday livability. The Executive Collection provides an upgraded option with features such as cabinetry and tile upgrades, 10-foot ceilings, and smooth walls across six named floor plans ranging from $462,900 to $789,900.

Buyers interested in new Evergreen Island single-family homes for sale can expect a selection of 3 to 5 bedrooms, 2 to 3 bathrooms, and 1- to 2-car garages, with home sizes ranging from approximately 1,767 to 3,048 square feet, depending on the collection and selected floor plan. Both collections are built by David Weekley Homes, providing buyers with the consistency of the builder’s construction standards and more than 45 years of homebuilding experience. This allows buyers to compare different designs while maintaining the same builder behind each collection.

For buyers weighing Evergreen Island homes for sale by owner against active builder inventory, most current opportunities in Evergreen Island are focused on new construction rather than resale homes. David Weekley continues to release new homesites and homes across both the Classic and Executive collections, giving buyers the opportunity to explore available floor plans and choose a home that fits their preferred size, features, and budget.

Schools

Zoned for St. Johns County Schools

Families with school-age kids buying in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf are zoned for St. Johns County Public Schools, one of the top-rated school districts in Florida. Specific elementary, middle, and high school assignments for Evergreen Island should be confirmed directly with St. Johns County Public Schools, since attendance boundaries can vary even between neighborhoods within the same Silverleaf master-planned community. Checking the latest zoning information can help families understand which schools currently serve their prospective home. Get in touch with Sarah for current updates.

Many families searching for houses to buy in Evergreen Island consider the reputation of St. Johns County’s school district an important reason for choosing this part of Silverleaf. The community’s gated setting, range of home options, and on-site amenities add to its appeal for households with children. Families comparing buy single-family homes in Evergreen Island across the Classic and Executive collections may also consider school zoning alongside floor plan size, homesite location, and the overall features of each home when making a final decision.

Because Evergreen Island is part of a still-growing master-planned community, buyers with school-age children should confirm current zoning directly with the school district and with Sarah at the time of purchase. School attendance boundaries can change as Silverleaf continues to develop and its population increases, so verifying the latest assignments before purchasing can help buyers make an informed decision about their future home and school options.

HOA & CDD Info

Low HOA Dues, and No CDD Fees

Silverleaf is marketed community-wide as having no CDD (Community Development District) fees, which sets it apart from many other master-planned communities in St. Johns County. Evergreen Island’s own HOA dues run approximately $999.56 per year, or about $83 per month, based on current builder listing data. Buyers evaluating new homes for sale in Evergreen Island should still confirm the exact current amount with Sarah or David Weekley’s sales team before making an offer, as HOA fees may change over time.

These relatively modest dues help support the community’s gated entrance, common area landscaping, and shared amenities, including the swimming pool, spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and clubhouse. The HOA structure allows residents to enjoy access to these community features while keeping the ongoing association costs relatively manageable. Buyers should also consider what is and is not included in the HOA when comparing Evergreen Island with other neighborhoods throughout Silverleaf.

Evergreen Island’s single-family HOA structure keeps the monthly association cost relatively low. This can be an important consideration for buyers balancing home price with recurring ownership expenses.

Buyers interested in Evergreen Island new construction should factor the HOA dues into their monthly budget alongside their mortgage payment, insurance, taxes, and other homeownership costs. Even without a CDD fee in the mix, understanding the combined carrying costs can help buyers evaluate long-term affordability and choose a home that fits comfortably within their overall budget.

Evergreen Island neighborhood entrance with a blue sign, palm trees, and homes beyond.

Why Buyers Are Choosing Evergreen Island

For buyers who want new construction with resort-style amenities already in place, new homes for sale in Evergreen Island stand out among Silverleaf’s newer neighborhoods. David Weekley Homes’ two collections, Classic and Executive, give buyers a genuine choice in size, price point, and finish level, paired with a full on-site amenity package that includes a pool, spray park, tennis and pickleball courts, and clubhouse. All amenities built into the gated neighborhood, set up for families moving to Evergreen Island.

Location adds to the appeal, with a firehouse and urgent care facility within Silverleaf, plus nearby shopping, dining, and top-rated St. Johns County schools. With homesites across both collections still available, buyers searching for Evergreen Island single-family homes in Silverleaf should act while a range of floor plans and homesite locations remain, particularly premium pond-view lots that tend to sell through faster than interior homesites.

Evergreen Island Photos

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf Location

Evergreen Island sits within Silverleaf, a roughly 11,000-acre master-planned community in St. Augustine, FL 32092, near State Road 23 and the First Coast Expressway. From Jacksonville, buyers can reach the community by taking I-95 South to St. Johns Parkway, followed by a right turn onto Silverlake Drive. This convenient regional access makes Evergreen Island an appealing option for buyers who commute throughout Florida.

This location places Silverleaf Evergreen Island homes within close reach of the Silverleaf amenity network, top-rated St. Johns County schools, and everyday shopping and dining options. Residents can also enjoy a comfortable drive to both historic downtown St. Augustine and Jacksonville via I-95, providing convenient access to employment centers, entertainment, beaches, and other destinations throughout the region.

Schedule Tour

Evergreen Island Frequently Asked Questions

Sarah Schwartz
Nocatee Realtor Office

360 Town Plaza Ave. Suite 320B
Nocatee, FL 32081

 

(904) 207-1209

Call Anytime: Open 24 Hours

 

PLEASE CALL BEFORE VISITING.

 

VERIFIED RATING: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐

 

More Than 250 5-Star Reviews

I pride myself on giving excellent service to each client I work with!

Theresa M.

Theresa M.

Sarah is an amazing realtor! We had multiple offers on our home in less than 12 hours of going live on MLS. She also helped find our dream home and close in less than 30 days. She is reliable, trustworthy, and efficient! If any...
Read More
Susan M.

Susan M.

I’m a Veteran moving closer to my family. My entire experience with Sarah has been A+ five stars Sarah is a true professional, trustworthy, knowledgeable, patient, and simply the best. She’s helped me view several homes and sel...
Read More
Rachel C.

Rachel C.

Sarah’s professionalism and patience is unparalleled. She helped find the perfect house for my family and negotiated the best deal for us. I will be recommending her to all of my friends and family!
Read More
Melissa Q.

Melissa Q.

Sarah makes home buying a breeze. As a first time home buyer I was very nervous, she took the time to explain everything as we went through a nd made me feel comfortable asking a million and three questions. We looked at multip...
Read More
Justin M.

Justin M.

Sarah is amazing to work with. She keeps you informed, touches base to make sure everything is on track and is a positive influence on all interactions. She is intelligent, so very kind and has a great repertoire as she's from ...
Read More
Hope S.

Hope S.

I can’t begin to explain how great Sarah Schwartz is! We decided to build a house here in Florida. Only thing was we were in Virginia and we nervous about building while we were so far away and couldn’t be here to make sure thi...
Read More
Dara B.

Dara B.

Sarah was a dream to work with. She was so in tune with our wants in our new home. She took take us to a multitude of homes until we found the perfect one for our family. She goes above and beyond as a realtor. Every detail thr...
Read More
Danielle B.

Danielle B.

Sarah helped us buy our dream house from across the country. We were in California and trying to buy a house in Florida. She made it so easy to look at houses on her site, pick our favorites, then she did walkthroughs with us o...
Read More
Craig Kendra M.

Craig Kendra M.

She is AWESOME! Sarah did an excellent job of communicating with us through out the process. With us being all the way in Hawaii and transitioning to Florida. We would recommend her to anyone. Thank you Sarah for making our dre...
Read More
Sherri L.

Sherri L.

Sarah did an incredible job for me listing and selling my house. She is tireless and always working on your behalf. She has a very calming way about her which was great selling my home of almost 29 years!
Read More
Susan H.

Susan H.

I'm a Veteran moving closer to my family. My entire experience with Sarah has been A+ five stars Sarah is a true professional, trustworthy, knowledgeable, patient, and simply the best. She's helped me view several homes and sel...
Read More
Veronica N.

Veronica N.

Sarah went above and beyond to help us find our dream home and she negotiated in our best interested throughout the process when it came to inspection results and appraisal. We couldn't have asked for a better experience during...
Read More
Thomas D.

Thomas D.

Sarah made the process of selling my home carefree throughout every process of the sale. Was always available to answer any question and ended up being one step ahead of me by the time I got around to asking the question. Will ...
Read More
Shaylee F.

Shaylee F.

Sarah was hands down the BEST realtor. We were out of town, FIRST homebuyers who didn't know what to expect or look for. Sarah made sure we knew what we were getting ourselves into and explained everything. Sarah knew all the a...
Read More
Angela P.

Angela P.

Sarah is awesome! We had a change of plans and had to find, make an offer, and buy a house in 2 months. She made it happen! She was always available, sent us inventory a few times a day, called and texted back right away, and d...
Read More
Rachel & Travis S.

Rachel & Travis S.

Sarah made our selling and buying experience absolutely seamless! She listened to our needs and wants, was considerate of our time, and was completely honest. She had all of the necessary resources and was patient and fun. Her ...
Read More
Ellen K.

Ellen K.

She is truly amazing! Very attuned to her buyer's wants and needs. There for you every step of the way. She has helped me buy and sell 4 separate properties! I wouldn't use any other realtor!
Read More
Joanna & Delmar H.

Joanna & Delmar H.

As a first-time home buyer, I was nervous and had so many questions! Sarah was prompt, patient, precise, and extremely friendly from my first inquiry to even after closing. My husband and I absolutely loved working with Sarah; ...
Read More
Karl F.

Karl F.

Sarah goes the extra mile and makes you feel as though you're her only client. If I have another real estate transaction, I will not hesitate to use her again. I also highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling real estate...
Read More
Mikayla W.

Mikayla W.

I feel so blessed to have had Sarah working with me through this whole process. This was my first home buying experience and Sarah was so helpful beyond anything I could have imagined! She made me feel like I was a priority and...
Read More

Ready to buy or sell in Evergreen Island?

Work with Sarah Schwartz, your Evergreen Island Realtor.

Image Form

Accreditations